Here I rank every Amnesia: The Dark Descent mod I play starting from 09/09/2023, based on their length, difficulty, story, scariness, level design, but most importantly, it's quality and effort put into it.
The top of the list contains the highest quality mods, with most effort — and as you go further down the quality and effort drops.
A mod here is counted as anything made in the HPL2 engine for Amnesia: TDD, that has a StartCredits script, or at least an indication where it's supposed to end. (Minigames are exceptions.)
You can recommend me mods to play on Discord, my name is wrenchynoodle.
I will take into consideration other opinions people may have about mods, but I'd want some reasoning as to why I should change the placement. You can also do this on Discord.
Full spreadsheet of mods: 🔗 View Spreadsheet